Reply to M.P. David Ward the anti-Semite
Jock L. Falkson
To commemorate Holocaust Memorial Day LibDem MP David Ward is reported to have said:
“Having visited Auschwitz twice ”“ once with my family and once with local schools ”“ I am saddened that the Jews, who suffered unbelievable levels of persecution during the Holocaust, could within a few years of liberation from the death camps be inflicting atrocities on Palestinians in the new State of Israel and continue to do so on a daily basis in the West Bank and Gaza.”
While I am sure that you accept the maxim that punishment should fit the crime, you obviously except Jews from this morally correct standard. Allow me to explain my umbrage:
I was not in Auschwitz.
I did not suffer unbelievable levels of persecution during the Holocaust.
I was not liberated from the death camps.
I emigrated from South Africa to Israel in 1993.
I have never met a Palestinian.
I have never committed an atrocity on a Palestinian on a daily basis in the West Bank or in Gaza. Nor elsewhere at any time.
You don`t provide a scintilla of evidence to prove your vile allegation that I, as an Israeli Jew, have inflicted and continue to inflict, atrocities on Palestinians.
Can you be so ignorant as to believe that all Jews think alike and act alike?
Are you so unintelligent as to tar all Jews in Israel with the same brush?
I marvel at your indifference to truth which permits you to extrapolate the alleged sins of some Jews on “the Jews”. You clearly believe it is right to punish “the Jews” for the alleged behavior of some. Such thinking is anti-Semitic by definition.
In the past it has lead directly to cries of “Kill the Jews”, “Dont buy from the Jews”, “Dont associate with the Jews”. These days it re-emerged under the anti-Israel BDS slogan: Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions.
Whatever, blaming the many for the sins of the few is immoral, unjust, even uncivilized. That Sir is what correctly defines you as an anti-Semite.
{ } { } { }
March 20th, 2013 at 6:56 am
You are too soft, kind and too politically corrected to David Ward and his evil minded and unmoral ignorance while comparing now days Israel behave toward Arab Palestinians with what the German Nazis did to the Jews in the 40`s. It is not a personal attack against you, but a brutal attack against Jews and the Zionist movement. David Ward acts exactly as Arafat+Abu Abbas inspired him to behave by their ideological commad that is called “The Phased Plan”. Arafat and Mahmoud Abbas had developed a practical work sheet to their terror PLO batallions in the ME and their political promoters in the West in 1974, called “phased plan to destroy the Zionist entity” and in short “The Phases Plan”. The Ratio of this plan is based on what they have learned from the Arab gangs in pre-1948 era and their cooperation and inspiration of their leader Haj Amin al”“Husseini with Hitler and Nazi Germany. Few thousands Palestinian Arabs went after the flag of their leader joining the German Nazis in executing and persecuting of the Serbs and the Jews in Yugoslavia and Greece. Haj Amin al-Husseini also visited Auschwitz extermination camp in June 1943, advicing and earging its commander Rudolf Höss to speed up the execution of the Jews.
Jews of Germany and Europe did not commit suicide bombing in buses or cultural centers of German and didn`t establish terrorist organizations to destroy Germany and to annihilate the Germans; the Jews did not aspire to destroy Germany and build under its ruins a Jewish state, even though the first Jews came to Germany in the first century AD with the legions of Romans, several hundred years before the invasion of Germanic tribes; the Jews were part of the German state and acted in its faith in order to strengthen its economic and political Features; Germans from within their soul and by the Nazi ethos developed extreme hatred and decided to exterminate the Jews.
However, Arabs in half of the lands of Judea and Samaria live under occupation under the protection of the IDF and the laws of the Geneva Convention (the other half live under the PA); Palestinian leadership split and conflicting among themselves, but sharing the same principle: they do not want to accept the existence of Israel; The Arabs launched a war of genocide against the Jewish community since 20`s; Israeli Arabs have equal rights and fewer obligations to fulfill (like not enlisting to the army) yet they want to destroy the Jews and establish an Islamic state in its place, although Jews came to Israel 1800 years before the first Arab conquests came (in the 7th century); There were always Jewish existence in the land of Israel oppressed and suffered under dozens of foreign invading imperialists conquests, most prominent among them were the Romans and the Byzantines, the Arabs, the Turks and the British. Until these days no Arab state or terror organization had recognized Israel’s right to exist as a Jewish state, while they insist to create the 23rd Islamic Arab Juden-rein state they want Israel to be “a state of all its citizens”. This is the anomaly of the crisis and the disgusting sordidness of David Ward.
If one needs to point today on the Nazi-like creature, in spirit and deed, no doubt you should point at the the Palestinians that incite their small children to hate Jews and kill them barbarically in the name of their Allah.
March 20th, 2013 at 7:35 am
Thank you Abe, for going to so much trouble to present an unusually detailed and effective comment below. Very much appreciated by yours truly and I’m sure by other readers too. Jock